Social change and the repetition of historical mistakes. Part 1
A hero today, a criminal tomorrow.
11/17/20267 min read


One of the key benefits of studying history is that it provides us with a greater ability to avoid repeating historical mistakes. Of course, in order to benefit from the historical knowledge we possess today, first of all it is essential to overcome one's intellectual arrogance. Put simply, it is necessary to abandon the assumption that what I believe in represents the universal and final truth. The underlying premise of this entire educational project is that our social consciousness is bound to evolve constantly alongside humanity's material and economic progress. Consequently, every generation tends to find itself at odds with both its predecessors and its descendants. In this sense, a historical mistake can be understood as a belief or an action that subsequent generations will regard as having been wrong. Once again, this does not mean that they themselves will have attained the ultimate knowledge of social truths. For after all, within the social world, all perspectives are relative.
There can be hardly any doubt that previous generations were so convinced of their own righteousness that they were prepared to die in defence of what they regarded as social truths. Moreover, to the extent that those generations now have passed away, they are neither aware nor bothered by the manner in which we judge them today. And things will be no different in our case. Many people living today will likewise die firmly convinced that history will judge their political and social positions favourably. Naturally, they will never experience the distress of knowing that they are ridiculed and condemned by future generations. Does anyone believe that Louis XVI of France or Adolf Hitler, to name just two examples, were not convinced that they were on the right side of history? But here we are.
In any case, it might be interesting to examine some of the historical examples that demonstrate how historical social change operates. Let us begin with religion and its institutional manifestations. European history is rife with bloodshed committed in the name of God, with the persecutions carried out by the Catholic Church against so-called heretics featuring prominently among such instances. Would the medieval Catholic knights, for instance, have accepted the argument that their participation in various religious wars would one day be regarded as a series of acts of pointless violence? Most likely not. And yet, here is a quotation from Pope John Paul II:
“While we praise God who, in his merciful love, has produced in the Church a wonderful harvest of holiness, missionary zeal, total dedication to Christ and neighbour, we cannot fail to recognize the infidelities to the Gospel committed by some of our brethren, especially during the second millennium. Let us ask pardon for the divisions which have occurred among Christians, for the violence some have used in the service of the truth and for the distrustful and hostile attitudes sometimes taken towards the followers of other religions.”
Around the same time of this statement, the following had been noted regarding this particular pope:
“On more than 100 separate occasions during his 21-year pontificate, the pope has publicly apologized for the shortcomings of Christians through the ages, on topics ranging from slavery to the Inquisition. He has asked forgiveness from groups, including indigenous peoples, other Christian churches and women.”
In fact, as early as 1982, John Paul II had acknowledged that “the Spanish Inquisition, which ordered thousands of 'heretics' burned to death and tortured countless others, was a historic mistake.” Later, in 1999, he expressed “deep regret for the cruel death inflicted on John Hus, and for the consequent wound of conflict and division which was thus imposed on the minds and hearts of the Bohemian people.” Surely, those responsible for committing such atrocities back then would never have accepted being labelled as standing on the wrong side of history. One can only imagine the astonishment they would experience if they were somehow brought back to life in our times. In any case, such historical judgements do not come only from the Pope himself. For example, in 2000, the leader of the Catholic Church in Portugal “issued a public apology to the local Jewish community for the suffering imposed on it by the Catholic Church, which in the 16th century supported an inquisition that expelled countless Jews or forced them to convert to Christianity.” Our collective social consciousness has evolved enormously since those earlier centuries; consequently, we now view the actions of the past in a very different light.
At the same time, most participants in modern nationalist wars are more than likely convinced that they are fighting for the greatest cause imaginable, namely, their own nation. Could anyone convince them that their actions today constitute yet another historical episode of the pointless waste of human life? Unlikely. But neither would the medieval Crusaders have accepted such an assessment. And yet, “on the Crusades, the pope in 1995 characterized these armed Christian expeditions as mistakes.” Hence, it is only a matter of time before violence in the name of a nation becomes as incomprehensible as violence in the name of religion. Finally, changing social perspectives have even prompted the Catholic Church to reassess how European colonial history should be viewed today. While the controversy surrounding Christopher Columbus's legacy, as well as that of other so-called explorers, is by no means new, the following statement dates from 2023:
“The ‘doctrine of discovery’ is not part of the teaching of the Catholic Church. Historical research clearly demonstrates that the papal documents in question, written in a specific historical period and linked to political questions, have never been considered expressions of the Catholic faith. At the same time, the Church acknowledges that these papal bulls did not adequately reflect the equal dignity and rights of indigenous peoples. The Church is also aware that the contents of these documents were manipulated for political purposes by competing colonial powers in order to justify immoral acts against indigenous peoples that were carried out, at times, without opposition from ecclesiastical authorities. It is only just to recognize these errors, acknowledge the terrible effects of the assimilation policies and the pain experienced by indigenous peoples, and ask for pardon. Furthermore, Pope Francis has urged: ‘Never again can the Christian community allow itself to be infected by the idea that one culture is superior to others, or that it is legitimate to employ ways of coercing others.’”
How well our contemporary Christian community avoids being “infected by the idea that one culture is superior to others” is illustrated by its treatment of migrants and asylum seekers. Nevertheless, such moments of historical reckoning are by no means restricted to official religious institutions. The question of colonialism has also been addressed by secular political leaders. Needless to say, the moral judgement of our time differs considerably from the way the sovereignty of other peoples was understood by previous generations engaged in colonial endeavours. For example, “through a historical agreement in 2008, Italy recognised and apologised for colonial atrocities to the Libyan population and offered monetary reparations.” Moreover, “the agreement set a historical precedent, marking the first time a colonial power formally acknowledged and apologised for colonial occupation.” One might wonder whether those who held power in Italy during the colonial period, along with their supporters, would have pursued such colonial policies had they known that Italians in the early twenty-first century would be apologizing for it. The problem, again, is that it would have been impossible to convince them that their actions and decisions would one day be regarded as historical mistakes.
And Italy is far from the only European country to have committed such historical wrongs. In fact, Germany is arguably the country most often associated with the latter. However, quite apart from the atrocities of the Second World War, Germany has also had to confront its colonial past. The following is an excerpt from a 2021 press release by the German Federal Foreign Office concerning reconciliation between Germany and its former colony, Namibia:
“Our aim was and remains to find a shared path towards genuine reconciliation in memory of the victims. This includes being unreserved and unflinching in naming the events of the German colonial period in what is now Namibia and in particular the atrocities between 1904 and 1908. We will now officially call these events what they are from today’s perspective: a genocide. Given Germany’s historical and moral responsibility, we will ask Namibia and the descendants of the victims for forgiveness. [...] Recognising our guilt and offering an apology however is an important step to come to terms with the crimes of the past and to shape the future together.”
Here we find the key words that explain all of the historical reassessments mentioned so far: “today’s perspective.” But what happened to the perspectives of the past? What happened to the social norms and beliefs that underpinned all the historical mistakes enumerated above? All this mental production simply died out alongside the generations that served as its medium. Nobody won the intellectual argument or the political debate. Nor did anyone manage to prove to our ancestors that killing in the name of religion or occupying foreign lands were unacceptable practices. All that happened was that the old generations passed away, while new ones grew up with a different social consciousness. Thus, a new and different world was born.
It is only within this new world that it has become possible for the president of France to acknowledge that the colonization of Algeria constituted a “crime against humanity”. Had earlier generations of the French held the same attitude, Algeria would not have been colonized in the first place. And while Emmanuel Macron could still be challenged over his refusal to issue an official apology, it seems much more urgent to relativize our own historical moment. Another manifestation of the intellectual arrogance mentioned above is the assumption that these laws of historical social change only applied to previous cases and previous generations, and that we are somehow different. Therefore, while Macron has essentially condemned the policies of his predecessors, to what extent would he be concerned over his own political stances in relation to the current events? For instance, would he be bothered by the fact that the future generations of French people will equally condemn him over his position on Palestine? Or does he truly believe that, on this particular issue, he is on the right side of history?
We shall continue this discussion in Part 2.
Sources:
1. https://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/homilies/2000/documents/hf_jp-ii_hom_20000312_pardon.html?utm_source
2. https://www.americamagazine.org/news/2000/03/25/signs-times-74/?utm_source
3. https://www.upi.com/Archives/1982/11/04/Pope-says-Inquisition-was-mistake/6005405234000/#google_vignette
4. https://www.christianitytoday.com/2000/10/catholics-apologize-to-portugals-jews/?utm_source
5. https://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/speeches/1999/december/documents/hf_jp-ii_spe_17121999_jan-hus.html?utm_source
6. https://www.humandevelopment.va/en/news/2023/nota-congiunta-sulla-dottrina-della-scoperta.html?utm_source
7. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/1369183X.2026.2717840?utm_source#abstract
8. https://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/en/newsroom/news/2463598-2463598?isLocal=false&isPreview=false&utm_source
9. https://1-e8259.azureedge.net/news/2021/1/20/macron-rules-out-official-apology-for-colonial-abuses-in-algeria?utm_source
The Progressive Optimist
Educational project dedicated to the understanding of historical progressive social change
© 2025. All rights reserved.
